In Search of the Crypto-Jews of Portugal

Exploring the Lost Jewish History of the Douro River Valley

Henry Abramson, PhD 

“Portugal,” explained Filipa Carretas, our local guide, “is about three things: fado, Fátima, and futebol.” Fado is the profoundly melancholy Portuguese national music, Fátima refers to a 1917 sighting of the Virgin Mary (in a town ironically named for the daughter of Muhammad), and futebol is, well, soccer. Portugal is also about a fourth, unstated element: the pervasive presence of a submerged Jewish population, vanished in the flames of the Inquisition five hundred years ago. With DNA studies indicating that 20 percent of Portuguese citizens have Jewish roots, it is not at all unusual to meet a local who did the family research and became a “Jew by surprise.” This is also Portugal.

The invisible yet palpable echo of the crypto-Jewish tradition resonates through Portugal like the far side of a conversation faintly overheard in another person’s cell phone. A rush of sibilants or an exclamation of laughter confirms the reality of the distant interlocutor, even though we do not see her before us. The history of Portugal’s crypto-Jewish community is similarly measured by absences—a mezuzah scar on a doorway, a bolt-hole for a Torah scroll hidden behind a false wall, a disappeared Juderia marked, if at all, by a 21st century plaque.

This summer I had the wonderful opportunity of  joining a group of Jewish history enthusiasts in a rather luxurious exploration of the Douro River valley as a scholar-in-residence  with Kosher Riverboat Cruises. Nestled between lush mountain terraces, the Douro flows from the interior of the Iberian peninsula through Spain and traverses northern Portugal before emptying into the Atlantic Ocean. Sun-kissed, the river is especially famous for its vineyards, which produce the famous Port wine (named for Porto, Portugal’s second city and home to one of its oldest Jewish communities). Well-read in the general history of the Jews but fairly ignorant of the specifics on the ground—this was my first trip to Portugal—I assumed that my role would be to  provide nightly lectures on the general history of the Jews of Spain and Portugal, leaving the more granular analysis of local sites to the competent Portuguese historians contracted to tour us on the land excursions. It soon became apparent, however, that the highly educated, academically curious passengers as well as our new Portuguese friends turned to me for responses to difficult questions of identity, belonging, and memory—subjects that stretched far beyond my training as a historian.

How, for example, does one remark on the Jewishness of a given site when nothing remains? Our guides were sympathetic and forthright about the darker aspects of Portuguese-Jewish history, but were sometimes not well-equipped to navigate the emotional minefields surrounding a synagogue that was confiscated as part of the purges of the Inquisition and transformed into a church. At moments like this, David Lawrence, a Sayeret Matkal veteran who transformed his Israeli logistical skills to Kosher Riverboat Cruises, would nudge me and say, “get in there and say something Jewy.”

So by night we retired to the luxurious accommodations abroad the Douro Serenity and enjoyed the incredible kosher cuisine of Master Chef Malcolm Green and the informative musical programs of “Entertainer in Residence” Howie Kahn, but by day we embarked on an ethnographic expedition reminiscent of the 20th-century explorations of Eastern Europe by Sh. An-Ski.

Neutral third-person descriptions morphed into more intimate, first-person accounts as confirmed Ashkenazim began to say “when we were expelled from Spain” and our Portuguese hosts spoke apologetically of “when we persecuted you.” This was, to paraphrase the Skipper, no longer just a “three-hour cruise.”

Salamanca 

Portugal boasts an ancient Jewish settlement that reached a population of some 30,000 by the end of the fifteenth century. Perched on the edge of the Iberian peninsula, Portugal earned a reputation for tolerance that had long attracted Jews fleeing Spanish oppression, including Don Isaac Abravanel’s grandfather Shmuel, who fled the 1391 riots and forced baptism to reclaim his Jewish faith in Portugal. It is fitting, therefore, that the first major stop of our river cruise began in Salamanca, a University town whose Jewish population was obliterated by the Spanish Inquisition and the 1492 Edict of Expulsion.

The Jewish presence in Salamanca is well-documented in ecclesiastical and municipal records from the 12th century on—first as a series of privileges conferred upon them by rulers seeking the economic advantage of Jewish merchants, later as their rights were eroded and properties were confiscated, including King Juan II’s 1413 dedication of Salamanca’s Beit Midrash and its surrounding courtyards as dormitories for students of the University. Traces of the community remain, sometimes as echoes or mirror images of their disappearance—a quiet street called Vera Cruz, for example, marks the street near a synagogue where Jews once prayed. In 1411 the fiery Dominican Vincente Ferrer (“the Angel of Judgement”), fueled by religious zeal, burst into the synagogue to proselytize the terrified minyan. In the midst of his impromptu sermon, Ferrer claimed to have a vision of crosses magically appearing on the prayer shawls of the Jews, which he interpreted as their secret desire to convert to the faith of the “true cross”—hence Vera Cruz. A mass baptism followed, as it did wherever Ferrer roused the population with zealous, sometimes violent, religious fervor. Ferrer eventually received sainthood from the grateful Church.

The forcibly baptized Spanish Jews (designated “New Christians,” “conversos,” or the  derogatory “Marranos”), maintained their connections with the traditional Jewish community throughout the fifteenth century. Living openly as Christians yet secretly as Jews (hence the term “crypto-Jews,” meaning “hidden Jews”), many continued to attend religious classes and services in the Jewish community, observed the dietary laws and the Sabbath, and married into other crypto-Jewish families. In 1478 the Spanish Inquisition was therefore instituted to root out Judaizing tendencies in this New Christian population. Led by the sadistic Tomas de Torquemada, the Inquisition used torture to exact “confessions” from conversos, describing their secret Jewish activities and, more significantly, naming other New Christians  whose faith was less than genuine.

The purge-like atmosphere engulfed all Spanish territories under Ferdinand and Isabella, a terror that continued for generations until it was finally abolished in the early nineteenth century. Swept up in its clutches were many prominent theologians and scholars, including the beloved lecturer Luis de Leon of University of Salamanca (1527-1591), whose credentials as an Augustinian Friar did not expunge the taint of his Jewish ancestry—that, and the fact that he dared to study Hebrew Scriptures in the original. Denounced as a crypto-Jew, he was imprisoned and interrogated. Returning to his classroom after four years of rough treatment, he famously began his class with the words, “as we were saying.”

Although initially concentrating on crypto-Jews, the Inquisition eventually directed its attention to the unbaptized Jewish community as well. Torquemada argued before the royal court that the stubborn persistence of Jewish practice was a consequence of the continued fraternization between conversos and the Jewish community. Historians argue about why Ferdinand and Isabella ultimately agreed to Torquemada’s plan to expel the Jews in 1492–was it religious zeal or greed?—but nothing could stop the throne from forcing its remaining Jews to choose conversion or exile in the Hebrew month of Av of that fateful year. Thousands of Salamancan Jews were forced from their homes and, like the first of Genie Milgrom’s fifteen crypto-Jewish  grandmothers, followed the Douro River westward as it flowed to the Portuguese border and beyond. We followed their trail.

Belmonte

In a break with Portugal’s history of relative religious tolerance, King João II initially refused to admit the estimated 100,000 Jewish refugees massing at his borders. Intensive petitioning finally moved the King to grant a six-month transit visa to 600 prominent families, at the usurious cost of six cruzados per person (approximately $20,000 US in contemporary currency). Despairing, many Jews chose to turn back, accept Christianity, and risk the depredations of the Inquisition. Others entered Portugal illegally, hoping to blend into the local population. Both João and his successor Manuel I imposed harsh antisemitic decrees aimed at forcing the Jews to accept baptism, including the kidnapping of Jewish children and exiling them to São Tomé, a recently acquired island off the coast of west Africa—according to the historian Samuel Usque, himself a Jewish refugee from Portuguese persecution, nearly 2,000 of the 2,500 children abandoned on São Tomé died there, perhaps eaten by huge indigenous lizards. By 1497, however, the Portuguese persecution reached its nadir with the mass conversion of all remaining Jews, both Portuguese and Spanish refugees, such that the entire Iberian peninsula was rendered Judenrein: free of Jews.

Amazingly, they persisted. Traces of crypto-Jewish activity over the following centuries are  recorded in Inquisition trial records and memoirs of those who managed to emigrate to safe havens like Amsterdam. It is difficult to comprehend the incredible stamina of these crypto-Jews, many of whom only learned their secret Jewish backgrounds upon reaching adulthood. Nevertheless, secret traditions continued through the centuries, right up to the 20th century, when a Polish Jewish civil engineer named Samuel Schwarz working in the Douro region heard rumors of a Portuguese community that practiced Judaism in a tiny village called Belmonte (the birthplace, incidentally, of Luis de Leon). Like the proverbial Japanese soldier stranded on a tropical island who was unaware that the war had ended, Schwarz reported that the Belmonte  conversos were skeptical that he was even Jewish. Only when he recited the familiar words of the Sh’ma prayer did they accept the fact that the Inquisition had not reached every living Jew.

 

Belmonte became a destination for ethnographers and historians seeking to document the  history of a secret community of crypto-Jews who risked their lives to continuously maintain their identity for half a millennium. A synagogue was dedicated in 1997, complete with a modern mikvah, and the crypto-Jews of Belmonte slowly began to integrate themselves back into the world Jewish community, with a large number of the youth emigrating to Israel. Their heroic tenacity was commemorated with a modern  museum that told their story, largely through ritual artifacts borrowed from countries where Judaism was freely practiced (possession of ordinary objects like Jewish books, kiddush cups or Chanukah candelabras were absolute contraband under the Portuguese Inquisition). Nevertheless, even these markers of identity tell the story well—skeleton keys representing the Spanish-Jewish custom of cherishing the possibility of an eventual return to their homeland, and covered lanterns that obscured the glow of Sabbath candles from inquisitive passers-by.

I was especially moved by the description of a local women’s ritual—indeed, much of the faith of Belmonte’s Jews was preserved specifically by  women—that I recognized from studies of 17th and 18th century Eastern European Jewish women. The crypto-Jewish women of Belmonte would utter special prayers over the preparation of wicks, calling them “prayer braids” before dipping them in wax to make homemade Sabbath candles. Dr. Chava  Weissler has discovered a similar practice in the shtetls of Eastern Europe, where Jewish women would visit the  graves of ancestors in the month of Elul and measure their perimeters with cotton that would be used to make the wicks for Sabbath candles throughout the year. This  beautiful custom, lost to modern Jewish women, not only united the living and the dead—it also united the Sephardic diaspora with Ashkenazic practice. Is it  possible that Tevye’s daughters received this ritual from Sephardic refugees?

Lamego

In an environment where every trace of Jewish civilization was intentionally wiped out and covered over—both by the Inquisition  and later by the crypto-Jews themselves, fearing  discovery—it was sometimes challenging to describe the civilization that once flourished in the Iberian peninsula without physical artifacts like synagogues, Torah scrolls and the like. Evidence of Jewish settlement was often occulted, attenuated, and disguised, as if reserved for initiates only. Lamego was a perfect case in point.

Graced by a 12th-century cathedral crowning a magnificent stone staircase (we watched two local penitents painfully climb the 686 steps on their knees, a feat that makes me grateful for fasting on Yom Kippur), the Baroque era renovations feature statues of Jewish heroes from the Hebrew scriptures and classically Portuguese blue ceramic outdoor tiles with subtle nods to Mary’s yiddishe mishpoche.

Even after five hundred years’ absence, traces of Jewish life in Portugal were everywhere. That church in the old Jewish neighborhood with a strange separate entrance to a second floor gallery—could that have once been a synagogue with a women’s balcony? The tablet-shaped mason’s marks on the medieval public cistern—a sign of a Jewish or crypto-Jewish stone worker? Amazingly, much of the local research is in its preliminary stages.    

  

Porto

After Lisbon, Porto is Portugal’s second city, home to one of the oldest Jewish communities in the country—so much so that the common name Rappoport is derived from the phrase “Rabbi of Porto” (although this could be a reference to an Italian city of the same name). Jews favored this northern city at the mouth of the Douro River because of its easy access to Atlantic markets, especially England.

 

On an architectural level, the Juderia of Porto is well-preserved, albeit rededicated to Christian purposes with the installation of monasteries and other ecclesiastical and secular facilities. One site in particular stands out—a nondescript white building houses a seniors center named, entirely without irony, in honor of “Our Lady of Victory.” Passing through a narrow corridor to the back of the building, one enters a pleasant airy space, used as a dining room with about ten small tables set for four seniors each. A modern rendition of the Last Supper decorates the southern wall, where a door leads onto a quiet patio overrun with gorgeous purple flowers and a steep staircase leading to an alley below.

Renovations to the dining room in 2013 revealed that hidden behind the eastern wall was an Aron Kodesh, carved directly into the stonework separating the building from its neighbor. Two compartments, a square space topped by a slightly larger arched tablet-shaped opening, with space for approximately six small Torah scrolls. Combined with sixteenth century testimony from Immanuel Aboab, a native of Porto, we know that this building once operated as a secret synagogue for crypto-Jews hiding from the Portuguese Inquisition. Placing my hand on the cool stonework of the Aron Kodesh—a gesture I have repeated many times in synagogue services—I felt a frisson of connection with my Sephardic brethren, an electric sense of solidarity across the centuries and an abiding sense of the eternity of the Jewish people. I was reminded of  the anonymous carving found in the barracks of a Nazi concentration camp, actually a verse from Samuel: netsah Yisrael lo ye-shaker, which in this context is best translated as “the survival of the Jewish people will not be denied.”

Indeed, the proof of Jewish survival in Portugal finds expression in the Mekor Hayim-Kadoorie synagogue. The congregation, which is heavily dependent on Israeli business people and travelers, serves as a gathering point for descendants of crypto-Jews, slowly discovering their Jewish origins and looking for a place to reconnect to their past. The interior of the synagogue, built in the mid-20th century with strong Art Deco influence, features well-chosen scriptural verses that seem ideally suited for this unique gathering of Jews. How would a young man, raised as a Catholic like his fathers yet contemplating a return to his pre-Expulsion roots, react to the verse surrounding the women’s balcony (Psalms 145:18) “God is close to all who call out to Him, to all who call out to God in truth”? Or for those who despaired that Jews and Judaism were completely destroyed in Portugal, would they read the verse that arches over the Aron Kodesh (Isaiah 43:11) as a subtle dig at their erstwhile Catholic faith: “I, only I, am God, and apart from me there is no savior.”    

Coimbra

Leaving the Douro River valley, we headed south to the medieval town of Coimbra, home to  one of Europe’s oldest Universities, established in 1290. The extent of Jewish settlement in Coimbra is increasingly evident—the city was possibly home to Jewish refugees who suffered expulsion from England in the same year of the University’s founding, as the city’s academic and mercantile foundations would have been an attractive destination. Indeed, repairs to the sewage system in the main shopping district—a section of the city that once housed the Jewish quarter—revealed a network of underground mikvaot that stretched back some seven hundred years (ironically, this discovery was made in 2013, the same year of the discovery of the hidden Aron Kodesh in Porto).

 

Unfortunately, the presence of a large number of theologians associated with one of the initial  faculties of the University meant that Coimbra served as one of the four seats of the Inquisition in Portugal. An estimated 11,000 suspected crypto-Jews were tried in Coimbra, many of them sentenced to public burnings in the town square. Like many sites in Portugal, the cheerful, well-organized square gleams with enthusiasm under the sunny blue skies, as if to  deny the horrors that were once perpetrated there.

The sense of incongruity is preserved in the beautiful library, called “the Jewel of the  University,” in which  rare books are exposed to and unfiltered sunlight and remain unprotected by modern climate control—yet the regular parade of visitors are admonished not to take photographs on their smart phones for fear of damaging the priceless manuscripts (including, for example, original commentaries on the Bible by Don Isaac Abravanel, a native of Portugal).

Óbidos

A priceless Portuguese gem is the remarkably well-preserved market town of Óbidos, home to an annual festival medieval culture.

Like most economic centers, it possessed a Jewish quarter, ironically located close to the modest cathedral. Our local guides pointed us to a building that stood on the site of a pre-Inquisition synagogue. Renovated in the 18th century after an earthquake damaged major structures (including the defensive wall that encircles Óbidos), the guides made the rather amazing claim that the otherwise unremarkable building dated from the seventh century, a holdover from the pre-Muslim Visigothic era in Portugal.

Is this possible? If the building really does date from the seventh century, it would be among the oldest synagogues in the world, certainly in Europe. The  historical record does preserve notation of an synagogue  in Obidos, already old by the Christian Reconquista, but is this the building?My  esteemed colleague Steven Fine of Yeshiva University—a specialist of Roman Jewish architecture who recently reconstructed the bas-relief scene of the sacking of the Temple on the Arch of Titus in it original color (!) version—is skeptical. I would love to take the local guide’s version of Jewish history over Dr. Fine, but I’m hard pressed to do so.

But something about the vision of the building—perhaps the covered arch on the right, or the gothic peaks over the doorways—evoked another image in my mind, the iconic Roman Vishniac photograph of the  Jewish quarter of Cracow (1937). Hard to reconcile the cheerful, eccentric yet pleasing proportions of the Portuguese structure basking in the Portuguese sun with the dreary, cramped and chaotic Polish street scene, but they both depict a single theme: the vanished world of Jewish history, one lost to the centuries-long persecution of the Inquisition, the other to the devastating ferocity of the Holocaust. I felt a strange kinship with my Sephardic siblings in Obidos.

 Lisbon

After the pastoral serenity of the Douro River valley and the pristine medieval idyll of central Portugal, arriving in the modern metropolis of Lisbon felt like a 500-year acceleration to the present day, or at least the 1970s, judging by the wood-paneled decor of the hotel room we occupied on our last night before returning to New York. Like the rest of Portugal, signs of incipient revival of Jewish life are evident, but they are like bright green shoots of new grass in a  once-mighty pine forest ravaged by fire. Sometimes, however, the shoots are themselves indicative of both the future and the past simultaneously, like the 2006 monument to the horrific 1506 pogrom that occurred in the capital city. Years after the forcible conversion, but before Manuel I’s promise of exemption from Inquisitorial investigation expired, Portugal was experiencing a drought-related economic crisis. A few churchgoers claimed to see an unusual halo surrounding an icon of the virgin Mary—remember Fatima?—and many flocked to witness the miracle.

As the story goes, a number of those Catholics in attendance were, of course, erstwhile Jews who were swept up in the forced conversion of 1497. They apparently could not contain their disdain for the credulity of their neighbors, and they were overheard as they expressed their skepticism, claiming that it was merely a trick of the light. As news of the remarks of these New Christians spread, a rage took hold of the population, and converso-Jewish blood flowed in the streets for days until order could be restored.

This too is Portugal.

And, of course, it is marked with a plaque.

Conclusion

What an amazing experience this was! I had no idea that exploring the Douro River valley with Kosher Riverboat Cruises would be so fascinating from a historical perspective. I’m completely psyched for our next cruise: the Danube in October.

Hello friends and colleagues:

Please accept my invitation to participate in a Global Study of Maimonides project, in memory of my father Jack Abramson a”h. It’s totally free and painless (insofar as teshuvah is ever painless). Here’s the next steps:

1. Choose your favorite social media platform.

I’m uploading daily videos, ranging from two to ten minutes, that cover the entirety of Maimonides’ glorious Laws of Repentance in the forty days between Rosh Hodesh Elul and Yom Kippur. This is not by accident–these forty days are traditionally reserved for the detailed personal self-analysis and introspection associated with the High Holidays. The videos are available on a YouTube channel called Maimonides on Teshuvah, on a Facebook Page also called @MaimonidesonTeshuvah , on TorahAnytime, and of course on a dedicated page on jewishhistorylectures.org.

2. Watch the Videos at Your Own Pace

I’m uploading them as fast as I can, and whenever possible I’m scheduling them to appear at 6:00 am every day (videos will not appear on Shabbat or Yom Tov, but will be scheduled for the day before).

3. Stay Tuned for Livecasts

I haven’t quite figured this out yet, but I was thinking of holding some live online sessions.

4. Optional: Read the Book

The book version is, I think, kind of cool. Lots more commentary and some tools on practical teshuvah. Optional, but I think you will like it–let me know either way! It’s available in hardcover, paper and ebook here.

Looking forward to learning with you! Here’s an introductory videos.

Henry Abramson

Hasidim of the Aish Kodesh should take note: this is likely the face of one of the murderers of Rabbi Kalonymus Kalmish Shapira hy”d. Jakiw Palij, a longtime resident of Queens, New York, was recently extradited to Germany for filing false information while immigrating to the United States after World War II.

Palij served as a guard in Trawniki, the labor camp where the Rebbe was imprisoned after his deportation from Warsaw. Beginning November 3, 1943, the Nazis instituted Aktion Erntefest (“Operation Harvest Festival”) as retaliation for the Jewish uprisings that were spreading throughout several concentration camps, including Sobibor and Treblinka. In a coordinated effort that spanned several labor camps, guards shot over 42,000 in the space of two days. The Rebbe was among the martyrs.

Click here for the New York Times article on Palij’s extradition to Germany.

Hello students, friends and colleagues–

We still have a few hours before the onset of Shabbat and the possible arrival of Mashiach, but if we have to make it through another Tisha B’Av–

If you are in Fort Lee, NJ Sunday morning or Crown Heights, Brooklyn Sunday afternoon, please join me for presentations on the implications of the Spanish Inquisition and Expulsion on our understanding of the meaning of Exile in our times.

Wishing you all an excellent Shabbat and a speedy consolation,

HMA

Thanks to Ben Rothke for this kind review of Torah from the Years of Wrath in this week’s Jewish Link of New Jersey. I am very grateful to be a part of the community that values and spreads the teachings of the Piaseczno Rebbe; nice to see positive reviews!

Keeping the Faith

By Ben Rothke | July 19, 2018

It’s a story that if it were not true, one couldn’t believe it. One of the greatest Jewish thinkers of the past century is martyred in the Holocaust, but leaves his treasured writings in a milk can buried in a devastated city. The can contains a plea to send the manuscripts to the author’s brother in Israel. After the war, the milk can is wondrously discovered in the rubble of the Warsaw Ghetto and makes its way back to the author’s brother.

In “Torah From the Years of Wrath 1939-1943: The Historical Context of the Aish Kodesh,” author Henry Abramson, dean of the Lander College of Arts and Sciences, takes the texts of the Piasetzna rebbe, Rabbi Kalonymus Kalmish Shapira, and maps the text to the historical context in which they were written during the war years.

Keeping one’s faith today is for the most part not a trial given the favorable living conditions most people find themselves in. But with starvation, war, the death of some of his family members, Rabbi Shapira still held onto his faith. Even as the darkness was increasing, and any possibility of survival was vanishing, the rebbe was still able to provide his followers with some semblance of hope, and more than that, deep meaning to what was going on.

What Abramson does in this fascinating book is to match the writing and sermons to what the Jews in the Warsaw Ghetto were experiencing. Rabbi Shapira had to deal not just with his own trauma and suffering, but that of thousands of his followers.

Much of Rabbi Shapira’s writings during those war years were cryptic. Abramson is able to deftly peel the layers off that and give the reader an explanation to the deepness of the messages. He is able to capture the depth of the Rebbe’s emunah at a time of unimaginable suffering.

It’s not clear if the Book of Job is a work of fiction or non-fiction. Job, whether real or imagined, dealt with questions of theodicy. Rabbi Shapira’s writing are perhaps the ultimate work in dealing with theodicy written since the Book of Job, from one who was suffering from the utter depths of destruction and devastation.

By Ben Rothke

 Ben Rothke lives in New Jersey and works in the information security field. He reviews books on religion, technology and science.

 

 

Paperback $24.95

Hardcover $27.91

Kindle $3.99

 

Hello everyone–

My father’s yortsayt is coming up next week, and as in previous years I hope to begin another cycle of study of Maimonides on Teshuvah. Please visit the Maimonides on Teshuvah page page to learn more about how to participate in this free, Global Study of Maimonides program. Posts will also appear on Facebook at

We hope to cover the entire Laws of Repentance in the forty days between Rosh Hodesh Elul (this year, the first post is scheduled for August 10) and Yom Kippur. Join me!

The Piaseczno Rebbe’s final sermons in the Warsaw Ghetto were addressed to a population terrified after the release of the Grojanowski Report, authored by the resistance based on the testimony of an escapee from the Chełmno Death Camp. News continued to filter into the Ghetto confirming the horrific details of the Nazi extermination facilities, including a report in mid-June from Biala Podloska that described sixty wagonloads of children under the age of ten and adults over the age of sixty who were selected and deported for mass murder. The murder of children is overwhelming for any human being, how much more so must it have been awful for the Rebbe, who devoted his life and literary efforts to the development of Jewish youth. His long sermon of June 27, 1942, discussed the importance of children to the Jewish people, and meditated on the cruelties meted out to this most helpless of populations:

The first antisemite, Pharaoh, pounced upon Jewish children: every male child born [shall be thrown into the Nile]. So too, the cruelty of the antisemite is always directed primarily against Jewish children, whether to murder them, Heaven forbid, or to force them into apostasy, as is well known from the evil decrees of previous centuries, may the Merciful One preserve us. This is, to our great anguish, apparent in our own days, for of all the horrific, murderous cruelty which is poured upon us, the Jewish people,  the murderous cruelty directed against young boys and girls is by far the worst. Woe, what has befallen us! More than this —when they seek, Heaven forbid, to murder the children of the Jewish people, it is not exclusively the children that are lost, Heaven forbid. The effect extends to their parents and grandparents who are in Garden of Eden, since the continued existence of the ancestors in this world is accomplished solely through their progeny, and when, Heaven forbid, they are wiped out, then the continued existence of the ancestors is severed, may the Merciful One preserve us. Regarding this we pray, “our Father, our King, take pity on us and on our infants and children,” for they are not merely our children, they are us…

The Rebbe expressed his bewilderment that the pain of the children was powerless to move God to act on their behalf:

In truth, it is astonishing that the universe continues to exist after so many screams such as these.  With regard the Ten Martyrs of the State it is taught that when the angels cried out, “this is Torah, and this is its reward?” A Heavenly Voice responded, “if I hear one more word, I will cause the universe to revert to primordial waters!” In our time, innocent children, pure angels, as well as great and holy ones of the Jewish people, are murdered and slaughtered simply because they are Jews…their screams suffuse the entire universe, and yet the universe does not revert to primordial waters. It continues to exist as if completely unaffected, Heaven forbid.

The Rebbe spoke on Parashat Matot, July 11, 1942, and then a final sermon was recorded on the Sabbath immediately preceding the day of national Jewish mourning, Tisha B’Av, on July 18, 1942. Both sermons focus on a theme prominent in the Rebbe’s early writings: the development of contemporary prophecy.

The Rebbe wrote often that the faculty of prophecy was accessible to individuals of spiritual sensitivity, and described a series of visualization exercises to encourage the development of this skill. To be sure, he distinguished contemporary prophecy from Biblical prophecy in quality but not necessarily in kind, arguing that elevated souls could access more direct communications with the Divine in a manner broadly similar to the inspiration of prophecy.  Problematic, however, was the Rabbinic teaching that prophecy may only be accessed while in a state of joy.

Prophecy is impossible amidst sadness. The Talmud states that this is also true for the study of Jewish law. Not only the investigation of a point of law, but even to comment on the suffering, is impossible with a broken heart and a crushed spirit. At times it is even impossible to force one’s self to speak at all, due to the enormity of the calamity, may the Merciful One rescue us. How is it possible to strengthen one’s self, if only a little, as long as the salvation has not yet arrived? How is it possible to elevate the spirit, if only a little, at a time of crushing oppression such as this? First and foremost, we must pray and have trust in God, the Merciful One, that it is impossible that God will so utterly cast out children from God’s presence. It is also impossible that God would abandon us in such danger as we experience now for the sake of the Blessed Name. Certainly, God will have mercy and will immediately save us in the blink of an eye.

On July 18, 1942. On that day, Adam Czerniaków recorded an ominous note in his diary:

A day full of foreboding. Rumors that the deportations will start on Monday evening (All?!) I asked the Kommissar whether he knew anything about it. He replied that he did not and that he did not believe the rumors. In the meantime panic in the Quarter; some speak of deportations, others of a pogrom.

The rumors, of course, would be proven true: beginning at 4:00 pm on July 22, the eve of Tisha B’Av, the Jewish community would be forced to provide the first daily quota of 6,000 deportees. Czerniaków refused to sign the order. The next day, when the Nazis specifically informed him that children were not exempted from deportation, he wrote a note to his wife that read,

I am powerless, my heart trembles in sorrow and compassion. I can no longer bear all this. My act will show everyone the right thing to do.

Retrieving a potassium cyanide tablet that he had secreted away with the intent of utilizing it when he could no longer reconcile his cooperation with the Nazi authorities with faithful service to the Jewish community, the President placed his diary on the desk before him, swallowed the pill, and ended his suffering.

The Rebbe, despite his personal agony over the suffering of his Hasidim, would deliver one final sermon on Shabbat Hazon.

Hardcover, Paperback and Kindle

We don’t know how exactly many of us were forced out of Spain by Ferdinand and Isabella’s cruel Edict of Expulsion in 1492, but conservative estimates put the number somewhere between 100,000 and 160,000 refugees. We climbed the northern mountains to escape into Navarre, we took to the sea hoping to find refuge in Mediterranean ports, and some of us even braved the Atlantic hoping to make a home in the New World. Our largest group, well over 50,000 Jews, sought asylum in neighboring Portugal—a country famed for its freedom of worship, sheltering Jews who fled the violence of 1391 and the recent persecutions of the Spanish Inquisition.

At first, we tried to cross the long land border into Portugal in an orderly and legal fashion. We sent a representative to King João II of Portugal and secured his agreement to allow temporary resident permits for 600 families and the privilege of purchasing transit visas for everyone else. The price was crippling: eight cruzados per every Jewish man, woman, and child—translated into 21st century American dollars, about $20,000.

For every Jew who could manage the payment, perhaps four others were forced to enter Portugal illegally, under cover of night along the loosely guarded land border. The only alternative was to accept baptism and return to our devastated homes in Spain. Many Jews did so, thinking perhaps that they could continue to practice Judaism in secret (known by the derogatory term “Marranos,” tens of thousands of these Jews and their descendants were mercilessly pursued by the Inquisition and ultimately murdered in public burnings).

By April 1493, many of us who entered Portugal found sea passage to other destinations. Others, especially those who paid for the transit visas, remained in government detention facilities; most lived quietly as illegal aliens in smaller communities throughout Portugal, trying to escape the notice of the authorities. King João II then adopted a zero tolerance policy—any undocumented Jews, including those with now-expired transit visas, were to be arrested and sold as slaves.

Two thousand Jewish children were forcibly separated from their parents. In a chilling act of incomprehensible cruelty, João shipped them off, aged two to twelve, to the uninhabited equatorial island of São Tomé off the coast of west Africa, and abandoned them on shore. Later Portuguese expeditions would reveal that only some six hundred survived. Many, according to the 16th-century historian Solomon Usque, were eaten by the huge lizards indigenous to the island.

João‘s cruelty did not extend to Portuguese-born Jews, but we and our children were not safe from his successor Manuel I. In late 1496 the new king determined to follow the Spanish example, ordering Portuguese Jews to choose between expulsion or baptism. He recognized, however, the economic value of the Jewish community, and put into place another child-separation policy to coerce us to choose Christianity over exile.

On the eve of Passover in 1497, Portuguese authorities raided Jewish communities and seized all Jewish children below the age of fourteen and baptized them as Christians. Eliyahu Capsali, a contemporary historian, wrote that when the Jews were searching for chometz in all the nooks and crannies of their homes, the Portuguese came with torches and searched them for our precious children. Parents were given the option of reunification with their offspring if they would but accept baptism—as in Spain, many did, and many lost their lives when the Inquisition crossed the border into Portugal thirty years later. In some cases, however, the children were simply lost—the government did not have a serious plan in place to reunite the families, and the children were never found again. In some cases, distraught Jewish parents committed suicide within the churches where they were to be baptized.

*****

I am a historian, not a politician. Like everyone else, I have my opinions about the long-standing immigration debate in this country, but in general I try not to share my views publicly. At the same time, I am a parent and a grandparent.

Last week I ran into a neighbor, another observant Jew, who mentioned in passing that he “could not care less” about the blanket child-separation policy occurring on the southern border. Me? I have difficulty sleeping, thinking about what this great country has done to these families, and the fact that months after the zero tolerance policy went into effect (and weeks after it was rescinded), over 2,000 children have still not been reunited with their parents, including over a hundred under the age of five. I just can’t understand how we–as Americans, as Jews, as human beings–can be so callous to this suffering.

I don’t want to get political about this. I don’t want to say it’s the fault of this person or that party. I want to do my part to bring us all together in agreement on something that should be obvious: separating children from parents as a deterrent to illegal immigration is horribly wrong. Yes, we need a solution to secure our borders. This is not it.

And if we don’t care? Shame on us.

Hoping that Moshiach will arrive before July 22. If not, then this is a great time to listen to the insights of Rabbi Zev Goldberg on the traditional Kinot. I’ll provide historical context. We did this last year and it was really meaningful. Hopefully this is the last Tisha B’Av we will have to mark in this fashion.